1986 Donruss Joe Carter #38

Joe Carter · Donruss · Base

1986 Donruss Joe Carter #38

Player

Joe Carter

Set

1986 Donruss

Year

1986

Card #

38

Condition Grade

PSA 8 (NM-MT) - Corners appear relatively sharp with minor wear visible on close inspection, edges are clean with slight chipping common to 1986 Donruss black borders, centering looks slightly heavy to the right/bottom edge, and surface has standard gloss with no major scratches.

Category

Base

Manufacturer

Donruss

Demand Level

Low - Niche appeal mostly for set builders or 1980s nostalgia collectors, as Joe Carter cards have stable but generally low liquidity.

Valuation

Raw (Ungraded) Value

$1.00 - $3.00

Graded Value

PSA 7: $5-10, PSA 8: $10-15, PSA 9: $25-40

Comparable Sales

Raw copies typically sell for $1.00 to $2.50 inclusive of shipping on eBay and COMC, while PSA 9 copies generally realize between $25 and $35.

Description

1986 Donruss Joe Carter Cleveland Indians baseball card, featuring the iconic black striped border design with a red team name banner at the top reading 'Donruss '86'. The card shows a close-up portrait of Joe Carter in his Indians jersey holding a bat over his shoulder, with a red nameplate at the bottom displaying 'JOE CARTER OF'.

Key Features

Popular mid-1980s star player, iconic 1986 Donruss striped border design, classic era card from a notable slugger's career.

Authenticity Indicators

High confidence. Card stock matches standard 1986 Donruss paper stock, print resolution and color tones are consistent with authentic production, and the card is not commonly counterfeited due to low raw market value.

Flaws to Note

Slight typical chipping along the dark blue striped borders, minor centering shift to the right, and possible soft corner upon micro-inspection.

Selling Guide

Where to Sell

COMC or eBay (best sold as part of a lot or set to offset shipping costs)

Selling Tips

Not economically viable to professionally grade due to high grading fees relative to the card's low raw value. Best sold raw in a penny sleeve and top loader, or bundled with other 1986 Donruss cards.

Scanned on 10/9/2026