1991 Topps Jeff Reardon #375

Jeff Reardon · Topps · Base

1991 Topps Jeff Reardon #375

Player

Jeff Reardon

Set

1991 Topps Base Set

Year

1991

Card #

#375

Condition Grade

PSA 5 (EX) - Estimated. Centering is heavily shifted left toward the top edge (approx 80/20 at the top left). Corners show visible rounding and white wear, particularly on the bottom right and top left. Minor chipping along the top edge.

Category

Base

Manufacturer

Topps

Demand Level

Low. This card is readily available in bulk and the player, while a 4-time All-Star, is not currently a high-demand HOF-tier target for most modern collectors.

Valuation

Raw (Ungraded) Value

$0.01 - $0.25

Graded Value

PSA 8: $5-10, PSA 9: $15-20, PSA 10: $40-60 (Value at PSA 5 is less than the cost of grading)

Comparable Sales

Raw singles typically sell for $0.50-$1.00 including shipping (effectively making the card worth pennies). PSA 10 copies occasionally sell for $40-50 to set-registry collectors, but this specific card is not a candidate for a high grade.

Description

A classic 1991 Topps Jeff Reardon card featuring the Boston Red Sox closer. The design includes the iconic 'Topps 40 Years of Baseball' logo in the upper left corner. Reardon is pictured in a headshot wearing his Red Sox cap and a gold chain, set against the bright yellow border characteristic of the 1991 set.

Key Features

Includes the 40th Anniversary Topps logo; featured during Reardon's tenure as a premier MLB closer; iconic early 90s 'junk wax' era design.

Authenticity Indicators

High confidence in authenticity. This card is from the 'junk wax' era and was produced in such high quantities that it is not a target for counterfeiting. Correct card stock and color saturation for 1991 Topps.

Flaws to Note

Significant left-to-right off-centering; rounded and softened corners; white paper loss on corners; slight edge wear/chipping on the top border.

Selling Guide

Where to Sell

Best sold as part of a lot on eBay, at a local card show in a 'dollar bin', or donated to a charity if sold individually. Shipping costs exceed the card's individual value.

Selling Tips

Do not grade this card, as the grading fees will far exceed the market value. It is best used to complete a set or sold in a bulk 'Red Sox' team lot or '1991 Topps' set lot. If listing, use 'Plain White Envelope' (PWE) shipping to keep costs low.

Scanned on 7/17/2026