1991 Topps Mike Fitzgerald #538

Mike Fitzgerald · Topps · Base

1991 Topps Mike Fitzgerald #538

Player

Mike Fitzgerald

Set

1991 Topps Base

Year

1991

Card #

538

Condition Grade

PSA 3-4 (VG-EX) due to significant surface wear (white scuffing/paper loss) and visible edge chipping.

Category

Base

Manufacturer

Topps

Demand Level

Niche/Low; primarily localized to Montreal Expos team collectors or 1991 Topps set builders.

Valuation

Raw (Ungraded) Value

$0.05 - $0.25

Graded Value

PSA 8: $5-10, PSA 9: $15-20, PSA 10: $45-60 (Note: Grading cost far exceeds card value).

Comparable Sales

Raw copies of this card typically sell for pennies in bulk lots. Gem Mint PSA 10 copies have sold for $25-$50, but cards in this visible condition have no significant individual market value.

Description

A 1991 Topps Mike Fitzgerald card featuring the Montreal Expos catcher in a dynamic action shot at home plate. The card includes the iconic 'Topps 40 Years of Baseball' logo in the lower left corner and the vertical 'Expos' team name banner. Red and blue borders frame the photographic field.

Key Features

Includes the Topps 40th Anniversary logo; features a veteran catcher in classic Montreal Expos gear; horizontal action photography layout.

Authenticity Indicators

Genuine card stock and period-correct matte printing; includes the 'Topps 40' logo used for the 1991 production year. This card is not a target for counterfeiting due to its common status. Confidence: High.

Flaws to Note

Obvious white scuffing or surface paper loss above the player's head; softening of all four corners; significant edge chipping along the right-hand border; centering is shifted slightly heavily toward the top-right.

Selling Guide

Where to Sell

Best sold as part of a lot on eBay or Mercari, or as a 'quarter bin' item at a local card show. Not profitable for individual sale through major auction houses.

Selling Tips

Do not grade this card; the fees will be much higher than the market value. List in a bulk team set of Montreal Expos or as part of a 1991 Topps starter set to maximize movement. Use '1991 Topps Expos' in keywords.

Scanned on 7/16/2026