1991 Topps Jay Buhner #451

Jay Buhner · Topps · Base

1991 Topps Jay Buhner #451

Player

Jay Buhner

Set

1991 Topps Base

Year

1991

Card #

#451

Condition Grade

PSA 5 (EX) - Centering is significantly off-top and there is a visible surface mark or stain above the player head.

Category

Base

Manufacturer

Topps

Demand Level

Low - This is a 'junk wax' era card with extremely high production numbers and low individual market value.

Valuation

Raw (Ungraded) Value

$0.05 - $0.25

Graded Value

PSA 5: $5-8, PSA 6: $7-10, PSA 4: $2-4 (Note: Grading cost far exceeds card value)

Comparable Sales

Individual raw copies frequently sell for under $0.50 at card shows or in 'quarter boxes'. PSA 10 copies have sold for $20-35, but this specimen does not meet that grade criteria.

Description

This 1991 Topps Jay Buhner card features the Seattle Mariners outfielder in a classic batting stance. The card includes the 'Topps 40 Years of Baseball' logo in the upper left corner and the Mariners team name in a banner at the bottom right. The design features a colorful inner border of blue and orange lines.

Key Features

Features iconic Seattle Mariners power hitter Jay Buhner; part of the Topps 40th Anniversary set.

Authenticity Indicators

Authentic card stock consistent with 1991 mass production; era-appropriate matte finish and ink saturation. Confidence: High.

Flaws to Note

Major centering shift toward the top edge; a dark circular spot or stain is visible in the top center border; fuzzy corner wear appearing on the lower left and right corners.

Selling Guide

Where to Sell

Best sold as part of a Seattle Mariners team set or a bulk lot on eBay. Not worth selling individually due to shipping costs.

Selling Tips

Do not grade this card. Market it to Mariners fans or completionists. Use 'Plain White Envelope' (PWE) shipping for the lowest possible cost if selling online. Only high-grade PSA 10 examples of this card carry significant value ($20-30).

Scanned on 5/1/2026