1988 Star Don Mattingly New York Yankees Autographed 8x10 Oversized Photo Card
Don Mattingly · Star Co. · Oversized Card / Signed Photo
Player
Don Mattingly
Set
1988 Star Baseball 8x10s
Year
1988
Card #
N/A (Oversized Photo)
Condition Grade
Estimated PSA 6-7 (EX-MT) due to visible surface scratches and edge wear in the lower left corner.
Category
Oversized Card / Signed Photo
Manufacturer
Star Co.
Demand Level
Moderate. Mattingly remains a hobby icon, but oversized items generally have a smaller buyer pool than standard 2.5x3.5 cards.
Valuation
Raw (Ungraded) Value
$60 - $125 (depending on authentication)
Graded Value
PSA/DNA Authenticated: $150-$250; PSA 8 with Auto 10: $350-$500; Non-authenticated: $40-$60
Comparable Sales
Authenticated Star 8x10 Mattingly autos typically sell for $150-$225. Unauthenticated versions with surface wear like this one often sell in the $50 range.
Description
This is a vintage 1988 Star Co. 8x10 photograph/card featuring New York Yankees legend 'Donnie Baseball' Don Mattingly. The image depicts Mattingly in his iconic pinstripes and batting stance. The piece features a blue ink signature across the jersey area. The MLB logo is visible in the bottom left corner, characteristic of the Star Co. licensed releases from the late 1980s.
Key Features
Features an on-photo signature from one of the most popular Yankees of all time. Oversized memorabilia from the Star Co. era is highly collectible for Yankees team collectors and Mattingly completionists.
Authenticity Indicators
The blue ink signature matches Mattingly's known 1980s-1990s signing style (specifically the 'D' and the 'y' tail). Confidence is medium-high; however, because Star Co. items were frequently reprinted or signed at private shows without COAs, professional authentication is required to maximize value.
Flaws to Note
Significant surface scratching and 'spider-webbing' visible under light throughout the right side of the photo. Minor corner softening and white edge wear at the bottom left. The signature shows slight ink skip but remains bold.
Selling Guide
Where to Sell
eBay (Auction with a high 'Buy It Now' option) or specialty Yankees memorabilia Facebook groups. Third-party authentication like PSA/DNA or JSA would facilitate a much faster sale.
Selling Tips
Get the signature authenticated by PSA/DNA, JSA, or Beckett. This will triple the value. Use keywords like 'Donnie Baseball', 'Yankees Legend', and 'Vintage Auto'. Ships in a rigid 8x10 top loader between two pieces of thick cardboard.