1970 Topps Thurman Munson/Dave McDonald Rookie Stars #189
Thurman Munson and Dave McDonald · Topps · Rookie Card (RC)
Player
Thurman Munson and Dave McDonald
Set
1970 Topps Base Set
Year
1970
Card #
#189
Condition Grade
PSA 3 (Very Good) - PSA 4 (Very Good-Excellent)
Category
Rookie Card (RC)
Manufacturer
Topps
Demand Level
Strong - Munson remains one of the most beloved Yankees. His tragic death and Hall of Fame caliber stats keep his rookie card in constant demand among vintage collectors.
Valuation
Raw (Ungraded) Value
$150.00 - $250.00
Graded Value
PSA 3: $250.00 - $350.00; PSA 4: $400.00 - $550.00; PSA 5: $700.00 - $900.00
Comparable Sales
Recent eBay sales for raw copies in similar mid-low grade range between $175 and $240. PSA 4 copies have recently settled around $475-525.
Description
An iconic 1970 Topps Rookie Stars card featuring New York Yankees legends. The card features a grey border design characteristic of the 1970 set, with Thurman Munson (Catcher) and Dave McDonald (1st Base) in separate portrait panels. Munson is shown in a batting stance, while McDonald is holding a baseball. This is the official rookie card of the 1970 AL Rookie of the Year and Yankees captain.
Key Features
Official Rookie Card of Thurman Munson, 1970 AL Rookie of the Year and 2-time World Series Champion. High-demand Yankees vintage card; 1970 grey borders are notoriously difficult to find in high grades due to chipping.
Authenticity Indicators
Correct coarse card stock texture for the 1970 era; appropriate color saturation and 'dot pattern' in the printing under magnification. No signs of common 'reprint' white borders. Confidence: High.
Flaws to Note
Significant soft corners and edge wear visible on the grey borders (white showing through). Surface shows some 'snowing' (white print speckles) and possible minor scuffing. Centering is shifted slightly toward the top-left.
Selling Guide
Where to Sell
eBay (Auction with high-quality photos), Heritage Auctions (if graded higher), or specialized vintage Facebook groups like 'Vintage Baseball Cards Only'.
Selling Tips
Due to the grey borders, surface scratches and edge chipping significantly affect value. Grading via PSA is recommended even at lower grades to guarantee authenticity and maximize liquid value. When listing, highlight 'Yankees Captain' and '1970 AL ROY'.