1991 Topps Pat Kelly Rookie Card #38

Pat Kelly · Topps · Rookie Card (RC)

1991 Topps Pat Kelly Rookie Card #38

Player

Pat Kelly

Set

1991 Topps Base

Year

1991

Card #

#38

Condition Grade

PSA 7 (Near Mint). The card exhibits significant centering issues, being heavily shifted toward the right border (roughly 80/20). The bottom right corner shows visible softening. Surfaces appear clean but the poor centering significantly limits the technical grade.

Category

Rookie Card (RC)

Manufacturer

Topps

Demand Level

Low. This is considered a common card from the 'Junk Wax' era, where production numbers were in the millions. Demand is limited to Yankees team set collectors or fans of 90s nostalgia.

Valuation

Raw (Ungraded) Value

$0.05 - $0.25

Graded Value

PSA 8: $5.00 - $12.00, PSA 9: $15.00 - $25.00, PSA 10: $50.00 - $75.00. Note: Current grading fees ($19+) far exceed the value of this card in the estimated grade.

Comparable Sales

Recent raw sales for this card usually range from $0.10 to $0.99 including shipping. Full 792-card 1991 Topps sets typically sell for $15 to $25, making individual commons worth pennies.

Description

This 1991 Topps Pat Kelly rookie card features the infielder in his classic New York Yankees pinstripes. The design commemorates Topps' 40th anniversary with the 'Topps 40 Years of Baseball' logo in the upper left corner. The card has a white border with a black and blue inner frame, showing Kelly in a fielding pose. The reverse typically features his minor league stats and a 'Coming Attraction' write-up.

Key Features

Designated Rookie Card (RC) for the long-time Yankees second baseman; features the iconic 1991 Topps 40th Anniversary logo; popular 'Junk Wax' era collectible for Yankees team sets.

Authenticity Indicators

Authenticity confidence is High. The card stock, printing dot patterns, and dull gloss are consistent with genuine 1991 Topps production. Counterfeiting for this specific card is extremely rare due to its high print volume and low market value.

Flaws to Note

The centering is poor, favoring the right side significantly. There is visible corner wear on the bottom right. The card also shows slight 'bowing' or curling common with this era's card stock.

Selling Guide

Where to Sell

eBay (as part of a lot or via eBay Standard Envelope), Sportlots, or local card shop 'bargain bins'. It is best sold as part of a 1991 Topps complete set or a New York Yankees player lot to maximize shipping efficiency.

Selling Tips

Do not grade this card, as the cost of grading will never be recovered. If selling online, use the 'eBay Standard Envelope' for cheap shipping. Accurate keywords include '1991 Topps', 'Pat Kelly RC', and 'NY Yankees'.

Scanned on 7/15/2026