2004 Donruss Elite Series David Ortiz #ES-16
David Ortiz · Donruss (Playoff) · Insert / Subset
Player
David Ortiz
Set
2004 Donruss Base - Elite Series Subset
Year
2004
Card #
#ES-16
Condition Grade
PSA 8 (NM-MT) - Centering appears slightly heavy on the bottom; corners show light white touches; surface may have hairline scratches typical of foil finishes.
Category
Insert / Subset
Manufacturer
Donruss (Playoff)
Demand Level
Moderate - Strong. David Ortiz remains one of the most collected modern legends, especially among Red Sox fans, though base inserts have lower volume than rare parallels.
Valuation
Raw (Ungraded) Value
$5.00 - $12.00
Graded Value
PSA 8: $25-35, PSA 9: $45-65, PSA 10: $150-200
Comparable Sales
Recent sales for mid-2000s Ortiz foil inserts range from $4 to $15 depending on the specific set. Elite Series inserts from 2004 typically sell for approximately $8-10 raw.
Description
A stunning 2004 Donruss Elite Series insert featuring Boston Red Sox legend David Ortiz (Big Papi). The card features a high-gloss foil border with a marbled grey lower section and a vibrant red background behind a powerful action shot of Ortiz at the plate. The 'Elite Series' logo is prominently displayed in the center with elegant serif typography.
Key Features
Hall of Fame player; Iconic Red Sox era; Early career insert from the high-demand 'Elite Series' brand line; Attractive foil design that is popular with set collectors.
Authenticity Indicators
Correct Donruss/Playoff branding; specific foil reflectivity patterns; high-resolution image printing. Confidence level: High. This is not a commonly counterfeited card.
Flaws to Note
Foil surfaces are highly susceptible to micro-scratching. Centering on this specific unit appears slightly off top-to-bottom. Minor corner wear is visible through the top-loader.
Selling Guide
Where to Sell
eBay (as a Buy It Now/Best Offer), COMC, or Red Sox fan groups on Facebook.
Selling Tips
Due to the foil nature, take photos out of the top-loader (but keep in the penny sleeve) to show the surface clarity. Use keywords like 'Big Papi', 'HOF', and 'Red Sox' in the listing title. Grading is likely not worth the fee unless it is a guaranteed Gem Mint 10.