1995 Topps Andy Pettitte #269
Andy Pettitte · Topps · Rookie Card
Player
Andy Pettitte
Set
1995 Topps Baseball
Year
1995
Card #
269
Condition Grade
PSA 8 (NM-MT) - Centering appears slightly heavy on the right border, but corners and edges look sharp with clean surfaces visible.
Category
Rookie Card
Manufacturer
Topps
Demand Level
Moderate - Steady demand from Yankees fans and set builders, though mass-produced nature keeps raw prices modest.
Valuation
Raw (Ungraded) Value
$2 - $5
Graded Value
PSA 7: $10 - $15, PSA 8: $15 - $25, PSA 9: $40 - $60, PSA 10: $150 - $250
Comparable Sales
Raw copies of this card typically sell for $2 to $5 on eBay, while PSA 9 copies generally realize between $40 and $60 depending on recent market fluctuations.
Description
Offering a 1995 Topps Andy Pettitte Rookie Card, card number 269. The front features a classic action shot of the New York Yankees left-handed pitcher in his iconic pinstripe uniform #46 mid-delivery on the mound, highlighted by a gold-bordered borderless design popular in the mid-90s set. Perfect addition for any Yankees or 90s baseball card collector.
Key Features
True rookie card of legendary New York Yankees starting pitcher and core Four member Andy Pettitte. Highly collectible for Yankees fans and 1990s baseball nostalgia collectors.
Authenticity Indicators
High confidence in authenticity. Standard 1995 Topps card stock thickness, gloss finish, and correct player imagery with no common counterfeit indicators for this specific base card.
Flaws to Note
Minor centering shift toward the right edge on the front. Light edge wear typical of 1995 Topps base card stock.
Selling Guide
Where to Sell
eBay or COMC are the best platforms for selling modern vintage base and rookie cards to reach a wide audience of collectors.
Selling Tips
Not recommended to grade unless submitting as part of a bulk bulk order due to the low raw value. Photograph clearly inside a penny sleeve and top loader under natural light. Ship securely in a rigid cardboard mailer.